Hong Kong: Between Two Systems, On One Very Long Night Out

Hong Kong: Between Two Systems, On One Very Long Night Out

6 min read

Share

Copied!
Tweet WhatsApp

“I was slightly too far back from the correct position, as Daniel later confirmed, but it was close enough to feel like a legitimate completion of something.”

My brother Daniel has had a photograph of the Hong Kong skyline on his bedroom wall for as long as I can remember. Night shot, taken from somewhere above the harbour, the towers of the financial district reflected in the water below. Coming off the ferry from Discovery Bay on my last full day in the city, the skyline materialised exactly as it does in the photograph, and I stood at the railing for longer than was probably strictly warranted. I had been trying to take the same shot for three days. I was slightly too far back from the correct position, as Daniel later confirmed, but it was close enough to feel like a legitimate completion of something.

Hong Kong was handed back to China by Britain in 1997, under an arrangement negotiated in 1984 that promised the territory fifty years of autonomy under the principle of “one country, two systems,” the formula that allowed Hong Kong to retain its common law legal system, its free press, its separate currency and its democratically elected legislature while acknowledging Chinese sovereignty. The Basic Law that governed this arrangement was designed to run until 2047. In 2011 the arrangement was fourteen years old, the relationship between Beijing and the Hong Kong government was already showing the tensions that would become considerably more visible in the following decade, and the city was proceeding with its life in the manner of a place that has learned to hold contradictions in suspension without resolving them.

Britain administered Hong Kong for a hundred and fifty-six years, beginning with the seizure of Hong Kong Island in 1841 during the First Opium War, a conflict initiated by the British government to force China to continue accepting imports of opium that the Chinese government had banned on public health grounds. The Kowloon peninsula was added in 1860 after the Second Opium War, and the New Territories were leased for ninety-nine years in 1898. The colony that resulted was built on financial services and trade and the specific advantage of being the most accessible point of entry into mainland China for international commerce, an advantage that produced a city of considerable wealth whose distribution was, by most measures, quite narrow. When the British left, they did so having introduced a degree of political reform in the final years of administration that they had declined to introduce for the previous century and a half, a timing that said something about the sincerity of the commitment.

Coming off the ferry from Discovery Bay on my last full day in the city, the skyline materialised exactly as it does in the photograph,...

Hong Kong: Between Two Systems, On One Very Long Night Out

The airport, designed by Norman Foster and opened in 1998 on land reclaimed from Lantau island, is one of those buildings that functions as a mission statement. It is vast, logical, and entirely self-confident. Walking the considerable distance from the aircraft to the baggage claim, you understand that you are in a city that regards infrastructure as a competitive advantage rather than a necessary inconvenience, and that has been right about this for long enough to have developed some conviction about it.

I arrived at the wrong hostel. There are three branches of the YesInn in Hong Kong, a detail absent from my booking confirmation, and I arrived at the one in Fortress Hill on the wrong island in the dark with a backpack that felt heavier than it had been in Tokyo. A taxi to the correct hostel. A lift to the correct floor. A New Zealander called Jay who greeted me with the warm efficiency of someone who has been there two days and considers himself a veteran. His roommates were David from Hungary, Murray from Australia, and Hyewon from South Korea, who described herself as being from the good Korea, which I thought was fair and accurate.

The evening that followed is documented more thoroughly in photographs than in memory. At some point I began performing the Macarena to music that was not the Macarena, which is a decision that seemed reasonable in context and which produced, by the third song, enough participation from the surrounding bar that the DJ played the actual Macarena, at which point the dance became unanimous and involuntary. I woke the following morning with twelve hours of recovery ahead of me and a partial account of the evening that has not substantially improved with time.

I woke the following morning with twelve hours of recovery ahead of me and
a partial account of the evening that has not substantially improved with time.

Discovery Bay, a ferry ride from Central, is where Hong Kong puts its expatriate professional class to live in comfort that the main islands cannot provide at equivalent cost. The residents travel around the island on golf carts that cost two hundred thousand Hong Kong dollars each, because private cars are not permitted on the island, an arrangement that is either ecologically considered or an accurate representation of how wealthy enclaves operate when they have enough money to design their own traffic policy. The houses are beautiful. The gardens are tended. The beach is clean. Three kilometres away, in the high-rise blocks of Tuen Mun and the densely packed tenements of Sham Shui Po, the city has a different set of facts about space and money.

On Sundays, the Filipino domestic workers of Hong Kong gather in their tens of thousands on the streets and covered walkways of the Central and Admiralty districts, their one day off in a working week structured by contracts that require them to live in their employers’ homes and work six days of seven. The Philippines is the world’s largest exporter of labour relative to its population, a situation produced by a domestic economy that cannot absorb the workforce it generates and by a remittance infrastructure that makes exporting that workforce financially sensible for the country as a whole even as it separates families for years at a time. Filipino overseas workers send home approximately thirty billion US dollars a year, a sum that represents roughly ten percent of the country’s GDP and that funds everything from school fees to house construction in provinces where local employment pays a fraction of what Hong Kong or Singapore or the Middle East will pay for the same labour. The women who gather on the pavements of Central every Sunday are in Hong Kong because the Philippines needs the money they send home, and they construct their community on the pavements because there is nowhere else for it to go.

I took the Peak Tram on my last afternoon and found the view. Took the photograph. It was not quite Daniel’s photograph. It was close enough.

1860

The Kowloon peninsula was added in 1860 after the Second Opium War, and the New Territories were leased for ninety-nine years in 1898.